Skip to main content

Those Who Do, Teach Better.

We’ve all heard that dreadfully incorrect phrase that exclaims “those who can’t do, teach.” I won’t elaborate on all the reasons why that condescending statement is woefully wrong here; talented professionals before me have tackled that notion. However, I will say that most teachers consider the profession a “calling.” That might sound clichéd, but only intrinsic rewards, true dedication, and a dash of idealism drive highly educated professionals to actively pursue a career with a relatively low income compared to educational level, time commitment, lack of adequate respect, and daily challenges and complexities. Clearly, teaching isn’t a soft option when it comes to career choice.

Because I teach at the secondary level, almost all of the teachers are experts in their field. Our APUSH teacher has a master’s degree in history, for instance. Not only that, but he has rich life experiences including world travel that allow him to share real-world examples and his passion for the subject with his students. Our Mock Trial coach studied and practiced law before dedicating his life to teaching. His real-world courtroom experiences help him instruct the students about the realities of the legal system. These are just a couple of examples from my hallway, but I could go on and on. Clearly, teachers can “do” what they teach. I don’t mean to neglect elementary teachers here; they must know a great deal about child development. Middle-school teachers have their own set of expertise as well.

When I had the epiphany at 30 that I belonged in the classroom, I wasn’t sure what grade-level I wanted to teach. I knew I had a knack for writing curriculum because of homeschooling experience, and I knew that I worked well with kids because of my large and successful Girl Scout troop. I was idealistic. Teachers had empowered me to overcome obstacles in my life; I wanted to do the same for others. The love of particular content isn’t really what drove me because I felt successful and passionate about everything from biology to band to creative writing. So I headed back to college, uncertain of my path, and studied the humanities. After all, this combined many of the subjects I love: art, history, music, architecture, and literature: all of the things that reflect and inform us of our humanity. I knew I would get to discuss important issues with my students and help them to become better people through exploration of these areas. At first, I thought I would teach history: the one subject I didn’t enjoy in high school. I always had that coach who didn’t actually care about history but had us read the textbook, color maps, and take tests. I found a love of history on my own, and I wanted to present it to students as exciting and relevant, so they would love it, too! In the process of my humanities degree, I took several literature courses. It wasn’t until Dr. Ed Garcia told me I was an English teacher that I realized what direction my path would really take. He even purchased an anthology text for me because he said I would need it when I taught literature. I insisted I was a history teacher in the making, but he reminded me that I already was an English teacher. Through class blogs, peer-collaboration and revision, and creative writing assignments, he said it was clear that this was my calling. And so this is how what I could “do” led to what I teach.

Since that time, I have been determined to continue to hone my craft. I read as many books as possible throughout the year and share them with my students. I write as often as possible – on my own, in front of my students, on long-winded blogs... This past summer, I spent the first month participating in the North Star of Texas National Writing Project. We wrote daily, published several pieces, completed a research inquiry project, taught mini-lessons, and read several texts. Then we wrote some more. We are still writing because we believe that teachers of reading and writing should actively and regularly read and write. Clearly, teachers can “do” what they teach, and do it well. I also firmly believe that teachers who continue to “do” are better teachers.
So here’s a shout-out to all the art teachers who craft on the weekends, the journalism teachers who publish articles in their spare time, and the band teachers who perform in their local symphony orchestras. Your students can sense your passion and knowledge, and enthusiasm for learning can be contagious. Let’s actively fight against the idea that teachers teach because they didn’t “succeed” in a given field. Teachers teach because they are committed to perpetual growth and demonstration to others of the importance of a chosen field.

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Station Eleven - a Review (With Spoilers!)

Warning: plot spoilers ahead... It's funny. Sometimes, the films and books I enjoy the most are the ones that I initially approached with hesitancy or ambivalence. Having recently finished the second book in a row for our book club that I found merely mildly entertaining, I had no real hopes for Emily St. John Mandel's Station Eleven , which I had not even heard of prior to the suggestion by one of our club members. With no expectations in mind, I skimmed the comments on the back cover and inside flap, but they didn't give much away. Thus, I started reading with almost no information about the book, its author, or even its genre. I knew it was post-apocalyptic, but was it dystopian? Was it similar to Cormac McCarthy's The Road ? Would it feature a teen love story as depicted in both  The Hunger Games trilogy and the Divergent series? I had several post-apocalyptic stories in mind as I began to read; boy was I surprised to find one that was different! Typically, aut...

Prayer to the Teachers to Forgive them for Solely Using TPCASTT

Last year, I began moving away from the formulaic TPCASTT and Somebody-Wanted-But-So methods of poetry analysis in my AP course. I still teach those methods of analysis; any tools my students have for decoding poems that serve as potential pathways toward understanding are valuable, and I want them to have as many tools as possible! However, I found that by emulating mentor texts, my students were able to find all of the poetic devices and reach a deeper understanding of the author’s work. This is simply a natural by-product of analyzing which parts of the poem – diction, syntax, theme, repetition and other devices – that they would like to mimic in their own work. My students came up with some of the most beautiful and deeply personal work I’ve ever experienced – some of which they performed at a poetry slam that they organized at the end of the year. To that end, tomorrow we will read “Forgive My Guilt” by Robert P. Tristram Coffin and “Prayer to the Living to Forgive them for B...

"Moist" - A Poem about a Much Maligned Word

“Moist” by Amber Counts In class, we were talking About words we hate. I heard a familiar term, A repeat offender, That seems to make everyone Cringe: Moist . Don’t believe me? Say it. In a room full of people, Ask how they feel About “moist.” Some will wince; Others will feel motivated To exclaim in protest. Someone almost always Says “that’s gross” Or “that sounds nasty!” But I always counter, Don’t you want your cake To be moist? This invariably begins a debate. What else could we call Moist cake But moist cake? Wet cake? Ew. Soggy cake? Not appealing. Juicy cake? I’m not even sure where to start With how wrong that is. Steaks can be juicy: Cakes cannot. So what do we use Instead of moist? Wet, damp, humid Tearful, watery, dewy Misty, rainy, steamy Muggy, clammy, dank Soggy, sweaty, sticky – None of these sound Like they would be good For a cake. Fun fact: According to an article By The Ne...